The Poor Pear

It is a fact that for most of us, our first exposure to pears was from a can, which I suppose is reason enough to turn against them. Even today I find it difficult to forgive a pear for not being an apple while at the same time, never ceasing to be amazed by its versatility.

Intellectually, I concede that the green round Comice is a charming fruit. It is sweet and juicy and when perfectly ripe, buttery. I remember eating one with a large piece of Brie on a small terrace in Avignon on a languid October afternoon. Later, I came to enjoy the sweet wine flavour of the Anjou and the tart taste of the long necked Bosc. The bell shaped Bartlett, which can be red or gold but always tastes sweet and musky, whatever its hue.

I could go one and yet I know that no pear can offer the satisfying crunch that an apple can, the wonderful feel of peel against teeth. A pear is more of a piece, softer and more fickle than an apple. A slight bruise and the total entity is ruined.

My experience compares to that of Varenne, the 17th century French chef who wrote:”The pear is the grandfather of the apple, its poor relation, a fallen aristocrat … preserving the memory of its prestige by its haughty comportment.”

Of course, comportment mores have changed since 1650 and today, to be shaped like a pear is not a symbol of aristocracy but a life sentence, one to be avoided at all costs.

Pears should be purchased when firm, when there is a slight give to the stem and it is best to let them ripen in a bowl away from the sun. Since the best tasting pears –Comice, Bartlett and Anjou – tend to fall apart when cooked, the cook is left with the less alluring but more accommodating varieties: Bosc, Winter Nelis and Seckel. But even with these, you must proceed gingerly. Roasting a pear requires less heat and more butter and sugar than roasting an apple, and poaching a pear, whether to be served with a classic chocolate sauce or ice cream is more of a coddle than a poach. Even the pear equivalent of applesauce must be cooked very carefully.

Though it is not an apple, I admire the pear for its ability to conjure different faces in the face of different spices; its sweet predilection for assuming warm, sweet and vaguely mysterious flavours as the weather gets cold.

The temperamental nature of the pear gives it an immediacy an apple could never have, a way of softening and giving that I, in my rigidity, can’t muster. But that’s only because I came to know the pear first in a can.

 

Pan Roasted Pears with Honey, Hazelnuts and Stilton

 

Four servings

 

½ cup hazelnuts

2 teaspoons unsalted butter

2 large firm pears, peeled, halved and cored

1/3 cup honey

4 ounce wedge Stilton cheese, quartered

 

1)     Preheat the oven to 350 F. Place the hazelnuts on a baking sheet and bake until toasted, about 10 minutes. Place the nuts between 2 kitchen towels and rub to remove as much skin as possible. Coarsely chop the nuts and set aside.

2)     Melt the butter in a medium size cast-iron skillet over medium high heat. Add the pears and cook until caramelized on both sides, about 3 to 5 minutes. Lower the heat and add the honey to the skillet. When the honey melts, turn the pears to coat them on both sides. Cover and cook until the pears are tender but not too soft, about 5 minutes.

3)     Cut each pear half across into ¼ inch thick slices, but keep the shape intact. Place each pear half onto a plate and fan it forward. Place a piece of Stilton beside the pears and scatter each plate with some of the Hazelnuts. Serve immediately.

 

back