Tomato Salad

To my way of thinking, tomatoes and lettuce are not a happy combination. In a sandwich with bacon and mayonnaise, yes, but not in a salad. I want to write that they taste too much the same; that’s what my tongue tells me, even if my brain says that they have nothing in common at all. All I know is that their flavours simply don’t work well together without a host of intermediaries or some chef trick to pull the thing off. Even Greek salad is better without any lettuce, and an argument could be made that this dish too, in its best and purest form, never contained lettuce in the first place.

So, let there be lettuce salads and tomato salads. We know all about the former; lettuce has been having a renaissance of sorts lately. But tomatoes, conversely are facing a rough time, and it might be a good thing to remind ourselves what a good thing they are, just sliced thick, set out flat on a plate, and sprinkled with olive oil and seasoned with a grind of black pepper and some sea salt.

And, to take it one step further, a pinch of fresh herbs. Parsley would do, I suppose, but there is a special affinity between tomato and basil, tomato and thyme, tomato and oregano – you can’t want for choices. This time, after adding the herb, dribble the slices with some fruity olive oil, shower them with pepper, and let them sit for a good hour or so in a cool place (not the refrigerator) before serving them. Salt them only when you pull up your chair to eat; otherwise it draws out the juices and makes them flabby.

The most popular Mediterranean salad, found from Spain to Turkey, is a combination of roughly cut chunks of tomato tossed in a bowl with small pieces of sweet onion (a red salad onion will do nicely, although a specialty onion like a Vidalia is a special treat) dressed with a good fruity olive oil and some freshly squeezed lemon or lime juice, and that grinding of pepper. This, too, should be put aside for an hour or so to let the flavours mingle … and salted only at the last moment.

This tomato and onion combination, is also a salad that herbs will enhance – big torn pieces of basil, a fragrant sprig of oregano. The Portuguese add a generous amount of minced watercress and a tiny pinch of minced coriander. The Greeks mingle a little basil and oregano with a lot of fresh mint and stir that in with a handful of black brined olives, again, all dressed with olive oil and a few drops of lemon juice or good wine vinegar.

I won’t give specific proportions here because individual tolerances to fresh herbs vary enormously. Mix them tiny pinch by pinch into your mixture of tomatoes and onions – or tomatoes alone – until you find the balance that suits you.

The final ingredient to this most perfect of salads is a portion of cheese. The standard Greek salad should not blind you to the fact that crumbled feta and tomatoes mix well together by themselves, enhanced perhaps with a few black olives and a pinch of parsley or oregano. A slightly more complicated version adds slivered bell peppers as well.

Equally successful is the popular Italian combination of tomatoes, basil, onion, and mozzarella. To prepare this salad properly, the ingredients should all be at room temperature, and mixed together with olive oil, a little crushed garlic, and a generous amount of torn fresh basil. Season with freshly ground pepper but again hold the salt until the end, and let the mixture marinate together in a cool spot in the kitchen for an hour or two. Served with a loaf of bread and a bottle of simple red wine, it is a feast all of itself.

Finally, if there is no time to let this mixture mingle together for the required hour, prepare it thusly. Preheat the oven to 350 F. Slice the tomatoes as thinly as possible with a sharp knife. Then slice the cheese the same way (mozzarella can be cut into thin slices if you dip the blade of the knife in boiling water between slices). Cut your loaf of bread in half lengthwise. Set one half aside for some other sue and layer the other with the sliced tomatoes, the mozzarella, and, alternatively, a basil leaf or a ring of sweet red onion, or both. When half the loaf is covered, dribble it with olive oil in which a little garlic has been mixed and grind some pepper over all. Bake in the oven just until the bread is crusty and the cheese melted – no more than ten minutes. Serve at once; cut into wedges with salt and olives at the side.

 

back